Calls to reform export licensing system - Museums Association

Calls to reform export licensing system

Export licensing system weighted against museums, says Art Fund
Profile image for Rebecca Atkinson
Rebecca Atkinson
The Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) has said it may look at reforming the export licensing system following concerns that owners of works may refuse to sell to museums after funds have been raised.

Owners of works are currently required to verbally confirm their willingness to accept a matching offer from a museum as soon as the export licence is deferred and again in writing at the end of the first deferral period. But this is not legally binding and there have been a number of cases where owners have changed their minds, even though they had agreed in writing they would sell.

Stephen Deuchar, director of the Art Fund, wrote to culture secretary Jeremy Hunt last week calling for the introduction of binding obligations on owners to sell export-stopped work if a museum can raise a matching offer. The Art Fund believes the current system is weighted against museums.

“This will ensure all parties are clear from the start, and will remove the uncertainty among museums when deciding whether to launch a fundraising appeal for an export-stopped work of art,” Deuchar told Museums Journal. “It will also remove donors’ doubts about donating to a campaign.”

A spokesman for the DCMS acknowledged that there have been cases where owners of works have refused offers from museums or galleries, despite previously giving assurances they that they would accept.

He added: “This is extremely unfortunate as a great deal of effort and goodwill goes into raising this money and we will be looking again at ways to deter such practices.”

Last year, the owner of William Hoare’s Portrait of Ayuba Suleiman Diallo refused to sell the work to the National Portrait Gallery in London, despite it successfully raising enough funds to match an offer at auction by the Qatar Museum Authority (QMA). Instead, QMA agreed to lend the work to the gallery for a five-year period.
In another case, the Burrell Collection raised £389,600 – including a £150,000 Art Fund award – to buy an export-stopped jewel-encrusted tiger’s head known as the Tipu Sultan’s Throne Finial but the owner refused to sell the object to it.

Leave a comment

You must be signed in to post a comment.